Oklahoma remains one of a few States1 allowing non-capital sentencing of defendants by trial juries. The current jury sentencing statutes are largely identical to the earliest enactments. In all cases, the jury may assess punishment within the statutory range; and must assess the punishment upon the defendant’s timely request.2 If the jury assesses imprisonment or fine in excess of that authorized by law, the court must disregard the excess and pronounce the maximum penalty. Where the jury finds a defendant guilty but fails to agree on punishment, the court must assess punishment.3
Defendants who plead guilty have no right to jury sentencing, but denial of a trial defendant’s timely demand for jury sentencing requires remand for re-sentencing or modification. A defendant has no right to waive jury sentencing or demand sentencing by the court. The prosecution has no right to jury sentencing, either, but case law has fused the State’s constitutional right to jury trial on issues of fact (which already existed) with a right to jury sentencing (which didn’t).4
The trial court has a statutory duty to impose the punishment assessed by the jury when pronouncing judgment, with certain limitations. When a jury fails to assess punishment, “then, and then only can the court assess and declare the punishment.” The trial court may follow, or disregard, jury recommendations for a suspended sentence, may suspend a sentence of imprisonment assessed by the jury in whole or in part, may impose other sanctions by statute, and may also modify a previously imposed sentence in the public interest. Where the jury rejects a fine after being instructed that it may impose one, the trial court may not impose a fine at formal sentencing.5
Trial of a second or subsequent offense must be in two stages unless the former conviction is an element of the offense. No reference to a prior conviction is admissible in the first stage, unless permitted by the rules of evidence; e.g., to impeach the defendant’s testimony. The judge must instruct the jury to determine only guilt or innocence, and that punishment is not before them. After a guilty verdict, prior convictions may be proved. The court must then instruct the jury to determine the punishment.6
Where the trial combines charges in which prior conviction is an element with other charges, the court must first try the crimes for which prior conviction is not an element, and may then try the charge involving a prior conviction element and admit other prior convictions to enhance punishment. The prosecution may not use a conviction as both an element of a crime and a prior conviction to enhance the penalty for the same crime.7
References
- As few as six states retain some form of non-capital jury sentencing. Richard A. Bierschbach, Notice-and-Comment Sentencing, 97 Minn. L. Rev. 1, 55 n. 249 (Winter 2012) ↩︎
- 22 O.S.2021, § 926.1. In Fain v. St., 1918 OK CR 69, the defendant’s request for jury sentencing came too late, where the jury had already rendered a verdict of guilt and stated in the verdict it could not agree as to punishment. ↩︎
- 22 O.S.2021, §§ 927.1, 928.1 ↩︎
- Dew v. St., 1912 OK CR 374 (holding “a refusal to instruct the jury of this right, when requested by the defendant, is prejudicial error, as being a denial of a substantial right given to him under the statute”). Early cases often reversed the conviction, but 22 O.S.2021, § 929 provides that in non-capital cases, where the appellate court finds error in the sentencing proceeding only, it may remand for re-sentencing. The Court also unquestionably has the power to modify an erroneous sentence on appeal. 22 O.S.2021, § 1066; Clopton v. St., 1987 OK CR 189 (denial of jury sentencing was harmless where Court modified to minimum); Reddell v. St., 1975 OK CR 229 (“We do not agree with the defendant’s contention that a defendant may waive his right to have the jury assess punishment. Such reasoning is fallaciously premised on the view that the defendant has a right to have the trial court assess the punishment”); Love v. St., 2009 OK CR 20 (holding defendant could not waive jury trial without the consent of the State, and had no right to unilaterally waive jury assessment of punishment); see also opinion of Lumpkin, J., concurring in result (§ 926.1 does not grant the State standing to request or object to jury sentencing; prior decisions have improperly meshed right to a jury trial with the statutory right to sentencing) ↩︎
- White v. St., 1929 OK CR 49 (reversing and remanding judgment and sentence of 18 months where jury fixed punishment at 2 years and a fine of $500); see also, Bean v. St., 1943 OK CR 72); Luker v. St., 1976 OK CR 135; Leeper v. St., 1976 OK CR 233; Fleming v. St., 1988 OK CR 163; Dew, 1912 OK CR 374; Presnell v. St., 1941 OK CR 11 (syllabus); 22 O.S.2021, §§ 64, 22 O.S.2021, §§ 982a, 991a (trial court may suspend all or part of sentence of imprisonment; order restitution, reimbursements, and other sanctions; and modify an initial sentence on judicial review within 60 months); Metoyer v. St., 2022 OK CR 27 (where jury was instructed that it could impose a fine up to $10,000, and sentencing verdict included only imprisonment, court’s imposition of $600 fine at formal sentencing was plain error in violation of 22 O.S.2011, § 926.1). ↩︎
- 22 O.S.2021, § 860.1; 12 O.S.2021, § 2609; 22 O.S.2021, § 860.1(1) ↩︎
- Chapple v. St., 1993 OK CR 38 ↩︎